Nuclear pre-tRNA transcripts often contain an extension of the aminoac
yl stem formed by base pairing between the 5'-leader and 3'-trailing s
equences, but the -1 position preceding the mature 5' end is usually l
eft unpaired. Considering recently proposed tertiary structural models
for RNase P RNAs, we hypothesize that the -1 mismatch prevents a stro
ng, coaxially extended aminoacyl stem, which might otherwise stericall
y interfere with substrate positioning in the RNase P active site. Thi
s hypothesis is tested by creating uninterrupted aminoacyl stem extens
ions in four nuclear tRNA precursors that normally have a mismatched n
ucleotide at position -1, and comparing their cleavage rates with thos
e of the normal precursors. Determinations of K-m and k(cat) values fo
r a normal and an altered pre-tRNA(SUP53), which exhibits the most sub
tle structural alteration immediately upstream of the cleavage site, i
ndicate that the mismatch at position -1 is an important structural re
quirement for both substrate affinity and efficient catalysis (and/or
product release) by nuclear RNase P. This conclusion is further suppor
ted in vivo, where the pre-tRNA(SUP53) mutant precursor lacking the -1
mismatch is shown to accumulate.