Objective: To evaluate the results of elective colorectal operations,
to identify factors that influence the anastomotic leak rate, and to a
ssess the value of a covering colostomy. Design: Retrospective study.
Setting: University hospital. Subject: 134 consecutive patients underg
oing elective resection for a neoplasm (125 carcinomas and 10 villous
adenomas) of the colon and rectum. Interventions: 135 operations (one
for a recurrence in the anastomotic line). Main outcome measures. Morb
idity and mortality. Results: Two patients died (1%) and there were 29
complications (21%); 16 patients developed clinical anastomotic leaks
(12%) and 3 patients symptomatic strictures (2%). One patient who dev
eloped a leak died and 11 of the 16 (69%) were re-operated on. The res
t settled spontaneously. The only significant risk factor associated w
ith leakage was distance of the anastomosis from the anal verge (all 1
6 leaks were within 7 cm, compared with 44/118 without leaks, p < 0.00
1). Four patients who developed leaks were left with permanent colosto
mies. Protecting stomas had no significant influence, despite the fact
that only 1 of those that developed leaks had a colostomy compared wi
th 9/109 that did not. Conclusion: Prospective controlled studies are
needed to establish the true value of a covering colostomy after low c
olorectal anastomosis.