Mm. Nederlof et al., HETEROGENEITY ANALYSIS FOR BINDING DATA USING AN ADAPTED SMOOTHING SPLINE TECHNIQUE, Environmental science & technology, 28(6), 1994, pp. 1037-1047
Heterogeneity analysis is a helpful tool to select a proper model for
the description of ion binding to polyfunctional ligands. Two approach
es of heterogeneity analysis are discussed: the local isotherm approxi
mation (LIA) method and the differential equilibrium function (DEF) me
thod. For both methods, the approximate distribution function of a giv
en ligand system is a series of derivatives of the experimentally obta
ined binding function. To obtain reliable derivatives, a smoothing spl
ine routine is adapted for the present problem. The smoothing paramete
r of the spline is determined by a generalized cross-validation criter
ion in combination with physical constraints derived from the binding
function. With the thus obtained spline function, the distribution is
calculated. Error bars for the obtained distribution function can be c
alculated using the variance in the spline function. The error bars in
dicate whether peaks in the distribution are significant. The methodol
ogy ia applied to a synthetic data set to illustrate its capabilities
and limitations and is applied to copper binding to humic materials (d
ata set of Hansen et al.) to illustrate its use in practice. The quali
ty of the calculated distribution function depends on the experimental
error in the data, the number of data points, and the binding range.
On the basis of the calculated distribution function, a binding model
can be selected.