Objective: It has been hypothesized that individuals who cannot percei
ve elevations of CO2 will be less anxious than individuals with intact
CO2 perception. To test this hypothesis, children with congenital cen
tral hypoventilation syndrome, who have a potentially lethal chronic i
llness associated with lack of CO2 perception and thus provide a natur
al experimental group, were studied. Method: Rates of anxiety symptoms
and disorders in children with congenital central hypoventilation syn
drome (N=13) were compared with rates in an age-matched, nonreferred g
roup of community subjects (N=292) that included subgroups of children
with asthma (N=15) and other chronic medical illnesses (N=66). Anxiet
y symptoms were assessed with information obtained from structured int
erviews of the parents, which provided both total symptom scores and D
SM-III-R diagnoses. Results: The children with congenital central hypo
ventilation syndrome exhibited significantly fewer anxiety symptoms th
an all other comparison subjects. Two of these children (15%) met crit
eria for anxiety disorders, a rate lower than that of the whole commun
ity group (24%) and of the chronically ill comparison subgroups (32%-4
7%). The largest difference in the prevalence of disorder emerged betw
een the children with congenital central hypoventilation syndrome (15%
) and those with asthma (47%). In the comparison of children with cong
enital central hypoventilation syndrome and children with other chroni
c illnesses, a priori analysis showed that the former had significantl
y lower rates of disorders that have been linked to panic in the liter
ature. Conclusions: This study supports theories of anxiety that impli
cate CO2 perception in the pathophysiology of panic and related anxiet
y states.