BAYES ESTIMATION - A NOVEL-APPROACH TO DERIVATION OF INTERNALLY CONSISTENT THERMODYNAMIC DATA FOR MINERALS, THEIR UNCERTAINTIES, AND CORRELATIONS .2. APPLICATION
Nd. Chatterjee et al., BAYES ESTIMATION - A NOVEL-APPROACH TO DERIVATION OF INTERNALLY CONSISTENT THERMODYNAMIC DATA FOR MINERALS, THEIR UNCERTAINTIES, AND CORRELATIONS .2. APPLICATION, Physics and chemistry of minerals, 21(1-2), 1994, pp. 50-62
Internally consistent thermodynamic data, including their uncertaintie
s and correlations, are reported for 22 phases of the quaternary syste
m CaO-Al2O3 - SiO2 - H2O. These data have been derived by simultaneous
evaluation of the-appropriate phase properties (PP) and reaction prop
erties (RP) by the novel technique of Bayes estimation (BE). The therm
odynamic model used and the theory of BE was expounded in Part I of th
is paper. Part II is the follow-up study illustrating an application o
f BE. The input for BE comprised, among others, the a priori values fo
r standard enthalpy of formation of the i-th phase, DELTA(f) H(i)0, an
d its standard entropy, S(i)0, in addition to the reaction reversal co
nstraints for 33 equilibria involving the relevant phases. A total of
269 RP restrictions have been processed, of which 107 turned out to be
non-redundant. The refined values for DELTA(f) H(i)0 and S(i)0 obtain
ed by BE, including their 2 sigma-uncertainties, appear in Table 4; th
e Appendix reproduces the corresponding correlation matrix. These data
permit generation of computed phase diagrams with 2 sigma-uncertainty
envelopes based on conventional error propagation; Fig. 3 depicts suc
h a phase diagram for the system CaO-Al2O3-SiO2. It shows that the ref
ined dataset is capable of yielding phase diagrams with uncertainty en
velopes narrow enough to be geologically useful. The results in Table
4 demonstrate that the uncertainties of the prior values for DELTA(f)H
(i)0, given in Table 1, have decreased by up to an order of magnitude,
while those for S(i)0 improved by a factor of up to two. For comparis
on, Table 4 also lists the refined DELTA(f)H(i)0 and S(i)0 data obtain
ed by mathematical programming (MAP), minimizing a quadratic objective
function used earlier by Berman (1988). Examples of calculated phase
diagrams are given to demonstrate the advantages of BE for deriving in
ternally consistent thermodynamic data. Although P - T curves generate
d from both MAP and BE databases will pass through the reversal restri
ctions, BE datasets appear to be better suited for extrapolations beyo
nd the P - T range explored experimentally and for predicting equilibr
ia not constrained by reversals.