L. Cellerin et al., PROGNOSTIC FACTORS IN THE SURVIVAL OF PAT IENTS SUFFERING FROM NEUROMUSCULAR DISEASE AFTER AN EPISODE OF ACUTE RESPIRATORY-FAILURE, Revue des maladies respiratoires, 11(3), 1994, pp. 263-270
We have studied the survival of 49 patients suffering from neuromuscul
ar disease, who were hospitalised in the Respiratory Intensive Care Un
it between 1981 and 1990 (29 males and 20 females with a mean age of 4
9.3 +/- 17 years with a range of 15 to 79). The neuromuscular diseases
consisted of 8 with multiple sclerosis, 9 with amyotrophic lateral sc
lerosis, 8 with Steinert's disease, 11 myopathies, and 10 suffering fr
om miscellaneous neurological diseases. Initially 27 of the 49 patient
s had been intubated and ventilated. During the hospital stay long-ter
m ventilation was undertaken in 2 7 patients (21 by tracheotomy and 6
by nasal mask). The principal prognostic factor was the aetiology. Thr
ee groups of varying degrees of severity could be individualized: prog
ressive neuromuscular disease (amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and multi
ple sclerosis), primary muscle disorders (myopathies and Steinert's di
sease), and neuromuscular disease with little or no evolution (surviva
l at two years was 15%, 45% and 71% respectively for three groups. p =
0.001 by logrank testing). The other factors which influence survival
are age (p <0.01), the presence of false route (p <0.01), and the rea
son for hospitalisation (acute as opposed to chronic progressive deter
ioration, p <0.05). In a multivariate analysis the most significant fa
ctors associated with the diagnosis were age, the reason for hospitali
sation, and the existence of false routes. The initial treatment (intu
bation) and the prescription of long-term ventilation did not bring wi
th it any significant further information as to prognosis, compared to
the model which included these four factors.