F. Newcombe et al., MINOR HEAD-INJURY - PATHOPHYSIOLOGICAL OR IATROGENIC SEQUELAE, Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 57(6), 1994, pp. 709-716
This study addresses the possibility that cognitive sequelae-albeit of
a transient or minor character-can be associated with mild head injur
y. Twenty men (aged 16-30 years of age), whose post-traumatic amnesia
did not exceed eight hours, were examined within 48 hours of their acc
ident and again one month later. This unselected sample had no previou
s history of head injury. A control group of 20 men of similar socioec
onomic background, was selected from medical wards (where they had bee
n admitted for orthopaedic treatment or a minor operation). They were
also retested one month after the first examination. Neuropsychologica
l tests were selected to measure abilities often compromised after sig
nificant head injury, namely memory and attention. The experimental co
mponent consisted of the fractionation of a complex skill (paced addit
ion) to probe for deficits at different stages of information processi
ng: perception and input into storage; search for and retrieval of inf
ormation from working memory; and paced and unpaced addition. In gener
al, no significant difference was found between the experimental and c
ontrol groups, with the possible exception of an initial decrement on
two working memory tasks: probe digits and a keeping track task (where
the subject has to keep in mind and update a number of variables at t
he same time). The keeping track paradigm, ostensibly of ecological re
levance, may well be worth further exploration in memory research, and
in studies of more severely head-injured patients. It is further sugg
ested that the appropriate management and counselling of mildly head-i
njured patients may help to avert symptoms that are of psychological r
ather than pathophysiological origin.