PROMOTING SCREENING MAMMOGRAPHY IN INNER-CITY SETTINGS - A RANDOMIZEDCONTROLLED TRIAL OF COMPUTERIZED REMINDERS AS A COMPONENT OF A PROGRAM TO FACILITATE MAMMOGRAPHY
Rc. Burack et al., PROMOTING SCREENING MAMMOGRAPHY IN INNER-CITY SETTINGS - A RANDOMIZEDCONTROLLED TRIAL OF COMPUTERIZED REMINDERS AS A COMPONENT OF A PROGRAM TO FACILITATE MAMMOGRAPHY, Medical care, 32(6), 1994, pp. 609-624
In a one-year randomized controlled trial, we assessed the effectivene
ss of a computerized mammography reminder system as a component of a p
rogram to increase the use of screening mammography in three health ca
re organizations serving inner-city women in Detroit, Michigan (two si
tes of a health department, one HMO site, and two sites of a private h
ospital). Four thousand four hundred and one women older than 40 who h
ad visited a study site in the preceding year were randomly assigned t
o one of two treatment groups. Limited intervention (LI) included phys
ician and staff breast cancer control education, facilitated mammograp
hy appointment scheduling procedures, and elimination of out-of-pocket
patient cost for mammography (at three of five sites). Full intervent
ion (FI) included all components of limited intervention plus an addit
ional series of ''cues-to-action.'' These included a mammography remin
der form inserted in the medical record of women who were due to have
mammography, intended to increase physician referral for mammography a
ppointments, and patient reminders intended to increase completion of
mammography among referred women. During the one-year intervention per
iod 2,725 randomized women visited a study site. The 6-month mammograp
hy appointment rates among Fl women vary from 38% to 65% and the FI ra
te exceeds the LI rate at each site with differences from 13% (95% Cl,
6 to 20) to 29% (21 to 38). The annual completed mammography rate amo
ng FI women extends from 43% to 64% and exceeds the LI rate at each si
te by 12% (5 to 19) to 25% (16 to 34). After age-adjustment, the mammo
graphy intervention effect sizes among the five sites were not signifi
cantly different. The average increase in FI compared to LI was 18%. T
he computerized reminder system is effective in increasing the use of
mammography in each of the study institutions and the major effect is
on physician referral for mammography.