Sj. Duffield et Nj. Aebischer, THE EFFECT OF SPATIAL SCALE OF TREATMENT WITH DIMETHOATE ON INVERTEBRATE POPULATION RECOVERY IN WINTER-WHEAT, Journal of Applied Ecology, 31(2), 1994, pp. 263-281
1. The influence of plot size in assessing the impact of pesticide tre
atment on invertebrate populations in cereals was investigated. Within
-field experiments were performed in southern England in winter wheat
using the broad-spectrum aphicide dimethoate. 2. Post-treatment recove
ry was monitored using, in separate experimental designs, pitfall trap
s in the centre of treated plots of different size from 4 x 4 m up to
288 x 288 m, and pitfall traps in transects running from the edge to t
he centre of large treated plots. 3. Invertebrate population recovery
was shown to be dependent on the size of the plot treated. Two contras
ting patterns of recovery were identified: (A) recovery progressing fr
om the edge to the centre of treated areas; (B) recovery most rapid in
the centre of the large treated areas. 4. Type A recovery was associa
ted with the predatory groups Carabidae, Staphylinidae and Linyphiidae
. It is consistent with that expected from the reinvasion of the pesti
cide-depleted plots from the undepleted surroundings. The speed of a g
roup's recovery was shown to be a function of the invasion potential,
which in turn was related to the mobility and phenology of the group.
5. Type B recovery was associated with the prey groups Aphididae and C
ollembola. Predation pressure appears to be the dominant process in th
eir post-treatment population recovery, with recovery most rapid in ar
eas with the fewest predators. 6. The results suggest that small-scale
within-field pesticide evaluations would in many instances fail to pr
edict the impact of treatment on a commercial scale.