Two commercially fabricated esophageal applicators for low dose rate i
ntraluminal brachytherapy were compared using the dose non-uniformity
ratio (DNR). One of the applicators has a single afterloading catheter
while the other applicator has six afterloading catheters to accommod
ate low dose rate Ir-192 ribbon or wire sources. Five sets of source c
onfigurations, each with a different ribbon length in the range of 5-1
7 cm were analysed using the DNR. The DNR shows the delivery of relati
vely higher total doses at higher dose rates to tissues closer to the
applicators. The difference in the inhomogeneity of dose rates and the
treatment volume exposed to higher dose rates than the prescribed dos
e rate between the two applicators are minimal. The dose homogeneity i
s better for the single-source applicator while the worst dose homogen
eity for the six-source applicator is caused by the placement of each
source closer to the surface of the applicator. The implications of hi
gher dose rates were discussed using the alpha/beta model.