Pm. Meire et al., CONSUMPTION OF BENTHIC INVERTEBRATES BY WATERBIRDS IN THE OOSTERSCHELDE ESTUARY, SW NETHERLANDS, Hydrobiologia, 283, 1994, pp. 525-546
The number of waders in the Oosterschelde, S.W. Netherlands, declined
after a reduction in intertidal area due to the construction of a stor
m surge barrier and secondary dams, suggesting that the carrying capac
ity had been reached (Schekkerman et al., 1993). In this paper we pres
ent data on consumption and predation pressure by birds to explore whe
ther the reduction in their numbers is due to prey depletion or to oth
er factors. The total annual consumption of benthic invertebrates by b
irds in the Oosterschelde amounted to 1573 x 10(3) g ADW y-1 in the pe
riod before the coastal engineering works (pre-barrier) and 1500 x 10(
3) kg ADW y-1 in the post-barrier period. More than half of the total
amount of biomass is eaten by the Oystercatcher, and only seven (pre-b
arrier) or even six (post-barrier) bird species together take 90% of t
he total. Although the consumption by individual species may vary cons
iderably among years, the total consumption was remarkably stable, wit
h a CV of only 3-4% of the mean, especially compared to the variabilit
y of the prey populations. In the pre-barrier period, consumption was
lowest in mid summer, increased sharply from August onwards until a pe
ak was reached in January. A sharp decrease took place in March. In th
e post-barrier period, consumption peaked in October. The total consum
ption per unit area per year does not differ much between different se
ctors of the Oosterschelde, apart from a distinctly lower value in the
eastern part. Of the total amount of food taken by birds, only 0.1-0.
4% is taken in the subtidal compartment. In several study plots on an
individual tidal flat, there was a clear relation between consumption
and benthic biomass. The predation pressure was 13 and 23% of the stan
ding stock, in the post- and pre-barrier period respectively. When coc
kles, mussels and their main predator, the Oystercatcher, are excluded
from the calculations, the predation pressure of the other species wa
s 30 and 37% of the biomass, respectively. Predation pressure of Oyste
rcatchers in individual study plots varied from less than 10% to more
than 70% of the standing stock. On cockle beds the predation pressure
was positively related to the average length of the cockles present. B
ased on these results and a comparison with the literature we conclude
that, at least for several species that feed intertidally, carrying c
apacity could be limited by the stocks of food. This does not mean tha
t birds face food shortage each season. As the variability of the bent
hos populations is much higher than that of the bird densities it is l
ikely that at some times food is not limiting, at other times it is. O
n the other hand, consumption is very low in the subtidal compartment
and species feeding here could potentially increase substantially in n
umbers in the Oosterschelde.