Je. Max et Dl. Dunisch, TRAUMATIC BRAIN INJURY IN A CHILD-PSYCHIATRY OUTPATIENT-CLINIC - A CONTROLLED-STUDY, Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 36(3), 1997, pp. 404-411
Objective: To demonstrate the similarity of children with a history of
traumatic brain injury (TBI), particularly mild TBI, to matched child
ren without such a history, within a child psychiatry outpatient clini
c. Method: This is a chart review of patients presenting to a child ps
ychiatry outpatient clinic over a 3-year period. Children with TBI wer
e matched by age, sex, race, and social class to children with no hist
ory of TBI. Axis I and II diagnoses, use of special education services
, and IQ scores were compared. Results: Seventy-four (5.6%) of 1,333 c
onsecutive clinic cases had a definite TBI. Of these, 64 were mild. On
ly 3 of 59 comparisons that were made between TBI and control subjects
were significant. A developmental communication disorder cluster was
significantly more frequent in the TBI group. Autism and a pervasive d
evelopmental disorder cluster were significantly more frequent in the
control group. Conclusion: In a child psychiatry clinic, patients with
a history of TBI are virtually indistinguishable from matched childre
n without TBI. Caution should be exercised before attributing the chil
d's problems, especially long-term problems, to the TBI unless the inj
ury was severe or the child is exhibiting related phobic or posttrauma
tic stress symptomatology.