PRESSURE-induced amorphization of solids has been much studied since i
t was first observed in 1984(1). It was found recently(2,3) that some
materials can be amorphized reversibly under pressure, reverting back
to the original crystalline structure and orientation when the pressur
e is decreased. It has been suggested(4) that the presence of non-defo
rmable units is essential for this reversibility, these units acting a
s templates around which the original structure is reformed. Here we i
nvestigate this idea by comparing the effect of pressure on two clathr
asils-silica solids with open, microporous structures-with and without
guest molecules inside the pores. We have studied pressure-induced am
orphization of dodecasil-3C, which has cage-like voids, and dodecasil-
3R, which has two-dimensional channels. For both materials, our experi
ments and simulations show that amorphization is fully or partly rever
sible only when guest molecules are present suggesting that these do i
ndeed act as rigid 'organizing centres' for the reversible transformat
ion.