P. Toniolo et al., CONSUMPTION OF MEAT, ANIMAL PRODUCTS, PROTEIN, AND FAT AND RISK OF BREAST-CANCER - A PROSPECTIVE COHORT STUDY IN NEW-YORK, Epidemiology, 5(4), 1994, pp. 391-397
Epidemiologic studies have focused on the association between diet and
breast: cancer with conflicting results. Whereas a majority of case-c
ontrol studies indicate a role for the intake of total fat: and satura
ted fat, most prospective cohort: studies either are negative or indic
ate very modest associations. Only a few authors have examined the rol
e of meat: intake in relation to breast cancer risk. The aim of this s
tudy was to examine the relation between risk of breast: cancer and di
etary intake of meat, animal products, far, and protein. Between 1985
and 1991, we recruited 14,291 New York City women in a prospective coh
ort study of endogenous hormones, diet, and cancer in which they repor
ted on their recent diet: using a food frequency questionnaire self-ad
ministered at enrollment. From the cohort, 180 invasive breast cancer
cases diagnosed before December 1990 and five times as many controls,
individually matched by age, calendar time ar enrollment, menopausal s
tatus, and, if premenopausal, phase of menstrual cycle, were included
in a nested case-control study. There was an evident: increase in the
relative risk (RR) of breast cancer for increasing consumption of meat
. Women in the upper quintile of meat consumption as compared with the
lowest quintile, had an energy-adjusted RR of 1.87 (95% confidence in
terval = 1.09-3.21). There was a modest RR increase in the upper quint
ile of total and saturated far and no apparent association for other t
ypes of far, protein, dairy products, poultry, or fish. The study indi
cates that the elevated consumption of certain foods of animal origin,
such as red meat, may be a factor in explaining the postulated role o
f diet in breast cancer etiology.