Defeated resistance genes are genes conferring race-specific resistanc
e that have been overcome by compatible pathogenic races. Such genes d
isplay residual effects if they increase the host's level of either ra
te-reducing resistance or tolerance to compatible races. The objective
of our research was to investigate residual effects of defeated resis
tance genes on phytophthora rot [caused by Phytophthora sojae (Kauf. a
nd Gerde.)] of soybean [Glycine max L. (Merr.)]. We used near-isogenic
lines of soybean (cv. 'Harosoy') carrying resistance genes Rps1, Rps3
, Rps4, Rps5, and Rps6 to develop additional soybean genotypes carryin
g combinations of two, three, and four resistance genes. We evaluated
these genotypes for rate-reducing resistance and tolerance to phytopht
hora rot by assessing extent of root lesions, plant height, and plant
dry weight after 28-d growth in the greenhouse in pots with and withou
t inoculum. Race 7 of P. sojae was used because this race was compatib
le with all resistance genes present. In one experiment, 28 genotypes
carrying zero to four resistance genes in either homozygous or heteroz
ygous condition were evaluated with two replications; in a second expe
riment, 13 genotypes homozygous for zero, one, or two resistance genes
were evaluated with six replications. Genotypes carrying Rps5 showed
significantly more root rot than rps5 genotypes, possibly due to linka
ge of Rps5 with a gene or genes for susceptibility. No other significa
nt effects of Rps genes were detected. These results indicate that res
idual effects cannot be exploited in this pathosystem.