We discuss the claim that when the peak of a tunneling wave packet app
ears on the far side of a barrier sooner than would be allowed by caus
al propagation of the incident peak, this must be interpreted to mean
that the transmitted particles originate toward the leading edge of th
e incident peak. We examine the status of information about where in a
wave packet a particle is, both in terms of Bohm's deterministic pict
ure of quantum mechanics and in terms of a recently proposed Gedanken
experiment. We find that while there are very real senses in which thi
s interpretation makes sense, attempts to explicitly bring out this ex
tra information in the form of quantum-mechanical observables necessar
ily fail. It therefore remains ''hidden'' information, which we can de
duce indirectly from multiple experiments or from the principle of cau
sality, but which we can never observe directly in a single experiment
.