The photochemistry in methanol of 1-naphthylmethyl phenyl carbonate (3
) and 1-naphthylmethyl benzyl carbonate (4) has been studied. Products
resulting from both the 1-naphthylmethyl cation and the 1-naphthylmet
hyl radical are obtained for 3, but only from the cation for 4. Simila
r results were obtained for the corresponding 1-naphthylmethyl derivat
ives 5 and 6 of N-phenyl and N-benzyl carbamic acids. The product yiel
ds for all four compounds can be explained by a mechanism of initial h
omolytic cleavage of the 1-naphthylmethyl carbon-oxygen bond from the
excited singlet state. The radical pair generated then partitions betw
een the two pathways: electron transfer to form the ion pair or decarb
oxylation. For PhO-CO-O' and PhNH-CO-O', decarboxylation is rapid and
competitive with electron transfer. For PhCH(2)O-CO-O' and PhCH(2)NH-C
O-O', decarboxylation is slower, electron transfer dominates, and only
products from the ion pair are obtained.