The frictional resistances of 54 explanted and 5 new Charnley hip pros
theses were measured using one of two Durham hip function simulators.
The friction factor f was measured in both dry and lubricated environm
ents up to a viscosity eta of approximately 0.1 Pa s. The friction fac
tor values for the new prostheses were found to be 0.11 (+/-0.025) and
0.04 (+/-0.01) for dry and lubricated (eta=0.01 Pa s) regimes respect
ively. The distributions of f for the new prostheses were found to be
approximately Gaussian. However, the distributions for the explanted p
rostheses were skewed, with most retaining friction values similar to
those of new prostheses, but a significant proportion exhibiting incre
ased frictional resistance. For dry regimes 30% of the prostheses show
ed values of f in excess of 0.16, while for lubricated regimes (eta=0.
01 Pa s) 39% showed values of f greater than 0.07. All the joints indi
cated a mixed lubrication regime when analysed in terms of a Stribeck
plot. A weak negative correlation (P<0.1) between penetration depth an
d friction factor, under lubricated conditions, was found for the expl
anted prostheses and indicates that f is not the cause of the increase
d occurrence of loosening found with increased penetration in this typ
e of prosthesis.