N. Macleod et G. Keller, COMPARATIVE BIOGEOGRAPHIC ANALYSIS OF PLANKTIC FORAMINIFERAL SURVIVORSHIP ACROSS THE CRETACEOUS TERTIARY (K/T) BOUNDARY/, Paleobiology, 20(2), 1994, pp. 143-177
It is now widely recognized that a large number of Cretaceous planktic
foraminiferal species are commonly found associated with fully Danian
faunas in many K/T boundary sections and deep-sea cores. This ''Creta
ceous'' fauna has traditionally been regarded as representing the rewo
rking of older Cretaceous sediments into younger strata, though recent
isotopic data from some species indicates that, at least in these ins
tances, the reworking hypothesis is false. To further test this rework
ing hypothesis the biogeography of this ''Cretaceous'' fauna is compar
ed to the underlying uppermost Maastrichtian biogeography and to the b
iogeography of lowermost Danian planktic foraminiferal faunas. Results
show that there is no regular decline in species richness, extinction
, or faunal co-occurrence values for this ''Cretaceous'' fauna at prog
ressively higher (=younger) Danian stratigraphic horizons. Moreover, t
here is no compelling association between the stratigraphic persistenc
e of this ''Cretaceous'' fauna and shallow depositional settings. Inst
ead, this fauna is characterized by: (1) a close (and predictive) asso
ciation between ''Cretaceous'' and indigenous Danian species richness
values throughout the lower Danian, (2) a close numerical and geograph
ic correspondence between Danian speciation and the disappearance of '
'Cretaceous'' species from the Danian fossil record, and (3) a pronoun
ced similarity between changes in the general biogeographic structures
of the ''Cretaceous'' and associated Danian faunas throughout the stu
dy interval. These data suggest that the K/T planktic foraminiferal ex
tinction event exhibited a marked geographic structure with low and mi
ddle latitude faunas experiencing differentially high extinction rates
in the lowermost Danian zones P0 and P1a and high latitude survivor f
aunas persisting more or less unchanged into the overlying zone, P1b a
nd P1c. Taken together, these results challenge the traditional concep
t of an instantaneous uppermost Cretaceous planktic foraminiferal mass
extinction and its proposed causal connection to bolide impact.