Np. Gregersen et S. Nolen, CHILDRENS ROAD SAFETY AND THE STRATEGY OF VOLUNTARY TRAFFIC SAFETY CLUBS, Accident analysis and prevention, 26(4), 1994, pp. 463-470
This study focuses on the problem of traffic safety among children and
the effectiveness of voluntary traffic clubs. General doubts are grow
ing in regard to this traditional strategy of teaching and training ch
ildren how to act in specific traffic situations. It has been shown th
at their knowledge and behavior improve, but the effect on accident ri
sk is not clear. In this study, one model for traditional teaching of
this type, a voluntary traffic safety club for children, is evaluated
in terms of accident risk. The data have been collected through questi
onnaires to members and nonmembers of the club. Approximately 20% of S
wedish children are members of the club. The results show that members
do not have a lower accident risk than nonmembers. On the contrary, t
he risk in this nonexperimental study is found to be higher among memb
ers. The use of safety equipment is, however, higher among members. Th
e results are discussed in terms of systematic differences between the
groups, i.e. socioeconomics, and in terms of the possibility that the
general strategy of the club leads to overestimation of the safety ef
fect.