Soil water management practices may affect crop growth by reducing per
iods of excess or shortage of soil water The objective of this study w
as to evaluate forage yield and quality as affected by soil hydrologic
conditions imposed by four water management practices. The experiment
was conducted on a Muskellunge sandy clay loam soil (fine, mixed, fri
gid Aeric Ochraqualf) in northern New York during three growing season
s (1989-1991), each involving three cuttings of an alfalfa (Medicago s
ativa L.)-timothy (Phleum pratense L.) intercrop. Treatments consisted
of (i) drain open at all times (OD); (ii) drain closed at all times (
CD); (iii) drain open in winter, closed in summer (SC); and (iv) drain
open in winter and the water table at a target 0.6-m depth using a we
ir and supplemental irrigation in the summer (SW). Lack of drainage un
der CD resulted in longer periods of soil saturation and reduced yield
s by 9 and 16% compared with OD in the first and second growth cycle o
f 1990 and by 17% during the first growth cycle of 1991. Increased soi
l wetness after drain closure under SC did not result in yield increas
es compared with conventional drainage during dry periods and caused a
small decrease during a wet growth cycle. Maintaining a water table a
t 0.6-m depth resulted in 30% yield increase in the dry year 1991, but
none in 1989 and 1990. Soil temperatures were not affected by water m
anagement. When yields were reduced, crude protein and elemental (P, C
a, K, Mg) concentrations were generally higher, and fiber and lignin l
evels were generally lower, indicating that increased forage quality p
artially compensates for lower yields, especially under excess water c
onditions.