An. Barkun et al., USEFUL PREDICTORS OF BILE-DUCT STONES IN PATIENTS UNDERGOING LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMY, Annals of surgery, 220(1), 1994, pp. 32-39
Objective The authors determined the most useful predictors of common
bile duct (CBD) stones as diagnosed by endoscopic retrograde cholangio
pancreatography (PROP) in patients who underwent laparoscopic cholecys
tectomy (LC). Methods Prospective and retrospective collection of hist
orical, biochemical and ultrasonographic data was used. Receiver opera
ting characteristics curve analysis was used to determine optimal bioc
hemical cut-off values. Multivariate analysis using logistic regressio
n with generation of the best model identifying independent predictors
of CBD stones also was employed. Prospective validation of the model
was performed on an independent group of patients. Results Endoscopic
retrograde cholangiopancreatographies were performed before LC in 106
patients, and after LC in 33. Only four of ten clinical variables eval
uated independently predicted the presence of CBD stones. The optimal
model predicted a 94% probability of CBD stones in a patient older tha
n 55 years of age who presented with an elevated bilirubin (over 30 mu
mol/L) and positive ultrasound findings (a dilated CBD, and a CBD sto
ne seen on ultrasound). This model was validated prospectively in a su
bsequent series of 49 patients in which the probability of CBD stone w
as only 8% when all four predictors were absent. Conclusions The ident
ified independent clinical predictors of a CBD stone helps select a po
pulation of symptomatic gallstone bearers who benefit most from cholan
giographic assessment.