What causes cyclical unemployment; sectoral shifts or aggregate demand
shocks? Using a new index based on stock market prices, Loungani, Rus
h and Tave (1990) contend that sectoral shifts are the primary cause.
Loungani, rush and Tave's findings are suspect since they performed on
ly half the necessary tests. Missing is the important test, described
by Abraham and Katz (1986), of checking the index against job vacancy
rates. The result of this test, a negative correlation between the sto
ck market dispersion index and job vacancy rates, reverses Loungani, R
ush and Tave's conclusions by indicating that cyclical unemployment is
better explained by aggregate demand shocks.