A. Fonzi et A. Smorti, NARRATIVE AND LOGICAL STRATEGIES IN SOCIOCOGNITIVE INTERACTION BETWEEN CHILDREN, International journal of behavioral development, 17(2), 1994, pp. 383-395
This study is an analysis of the ''meaning giving'' process in childre
n when they have to classify empirical objects. There are three stages
to the experiment: (1) the children performed a classification task i
ndividually; (2) they performed it with a companion; (3) in the indivi
dual control situation they performed it again but alone. The aim of t
his research project was to establish: (1) how children change the mea
nings they give to objects when they move from an individual situation
to a social one; and (2) the role of the two children's different cla
ssification strategies in the negotiation of shared meanings. The samp
le consisted of 72 6-year-old children. Three different classification
criteria were distinguished: category; function; and narrative. The r
esults showed that children who used narrative criteria in the first p
hase (''narrative children'') modified them during the second phase in
favour of more categorial criteria. Analysis of the interactional pro
cess revealed that narrative children were significantly more willing
than ''logical children'' (who had used categorial criteria in the fir
st phase) to come to terms with their companion's point of view. In th
e third phase both types of children changed their classification stra
tegies, in part absorbing their companion's classification approach. W
e conclude that: (1) the personal approach to giving a meaning to obje
cts influences the individual child's interaction strategies; and (2)
the experience of comparison and social conflict modifies attribution
of meaning in narrative and logical children.