Hs. Mii et El. Grossman, LATE PENNSYLVANIAN SEASONALITY REFLECTED IN THE O-18 AND ELEMENTAL COMPOSITION OF A BRACHIOPOD SHELL, Geology, 22(7), 1994, pp. 661-664
To evaluate the potential for the study of Late Pennsylvanian seasonal
ity, detailed isotopic and elemental analyses were performed on a sing
le specimen of the brachiopod Neospirifer dunbari. Shell preservation
was evaluated by petrographic and cathodoluminescence microscopy. Carb
onate powders from 112 spots were collected from the sectioned shell f
or isotopic analyses, and 369 spots on the complementary thin section
were analyzed by electron microprobe for chemical composition. In the
nonluminescent part of the shell, Mg/Ca ratios were between 0.001 and
0.012, and Na/Ca and S/Ca ratios ranged from 0.003 to 0.012 and 0.003
to 0.021, respectively. Values of deltaO-18 vary between -2.3 parts pe
r thousand and -1.1 parts per thousand. Contours of O-18, Mg, Na, and
S concentrations parallel growth bands and reveal a record of 1 1/2 to
2 cycles. Mg, S, and Na contents varied inversely with deltaO-18. Thi
s trend is opposite to the expected diagenetic trend and is consistent
with the temperature dependences of Mg content and deltaO-18, thus im
plying preservation of shell chemistry. The approximately 1.2 parts pe
r thousand range in deltaO-18 values suggests a seasonal temperature v
ariation of 5 to 6-degrees-C (assuming no change in the deltaO-18 of t
he water). This high seasonality for the tropical epicontinental sea o
f Kansas supports climate-model predictions of enhanced continentality
in Pangean climate. Detailed stable isotope and element concentration
profiles across growth bands of brachiopod shells can provide quantit
ative records of Paleozoic seasonality.