Gl. Murphy et Pd. Allopenna, THE LOCUS OF KNOWLEDGE EFFECTS IN CONCEPT-LEARNING, Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition, 20(4), 1994, pp. 904-919
Three experiments investigated how knowledge influences concept format
ion and representation in a standard concept acquisition task. The pri
mary comparison was among arbitrary concepts, which had meaningless fe
atures; meaningful concepts, which had meaningful features from differ
ent domains; and integrated concepts, which had meaningful features in
terconnected by common knowledge. Experiment 1 found that learning was
superior for the integrated concepts but that there was little differ
ence as a function of feature meaningfulness. Experiment 2 suggested t
hat the integrated Ss were learning to form a knowledge-based schema a
s their concept representation because they did not distinguish the ty
picality of features that differed in frequency. Experiment 3 introduc
ed a category whose features were from the same domain but were not ot
herwise related. This concept was as difficult to learn and use as the
meaningful concepts were. These comparisons help specify the ways in
which knowledge does and does not influence concept formation.