Comparative correlation crystal field (CCF) analyses of the Er3+ (4f11
) energy level structure in YAG, LuAG, ErAG, ErGG, YSAG and YSGG syste
ms are reported. These analyses are based on the use of a phenomenolog
ical Hamiltonian model that includes 20 free-ion parameters and the ni
ne one-electron crystal field parameters plus one two-particle CCF par
ameter. The present analyses are carried out with a uniform Hamiltonia
n model and common crystal field levels spanning the lowest 12 multipl
ets. Comparison between the observed and calculated crystal field leve
ls yields good agreement with rms deviations between 7.7 cm-1 (Er:ErGG
) and 11.5 cm-1 (Er:YAG). The fits are in qualitative agreement-with a
b initio calculations of CCF effects and also with the results of CCF
of the Nd3+ ion.