BACKGROUND Urine calcium after an overnight fast is higher in osteopor
otic than in normal post-menopausal women. The question is whether thi
s is the cause or effect of the bone-losing state. OBJECTIVE To establ
ish whether the elevated obligatory calcium loss in osteoporotic women
is due to a raised filtered load of calcium or to reduced renal tubul
ar reabsorption of calcium. DESIGN Covariance analysis using total pla
sma calcium and its fractions as the covariates. PATIENTS Eighty-two u
ntreated post-menopausal women without vertebral compression and 137 u
ntreated postmenopausal with vertebral compression all between the age
s of 61 and 75 years. MEASUREMENTS After an overnight fast, calcium, a
lbumin, globulins, anion gap and bicarbonate were measured in the plas
ma, and calcium, sodium and creatinine in the urine. The calcium fract
ions in plasma and the calcium/creatinine and sodium/creatinine ratios
in urine were calculated. Bone density was measured in the distal for
earm. RESULTS The ultrafiltrable and ionized calcium in the plasma and
the calcium/creatinine ratio in the urine were significantly higher i
n the women with vertebral compression than in those without. On covar
iance analysis, neither total plasma calcium nor any of the plasma cal
cium fractions made a significant contribution to the difference in fa
sting urine calcium between normal and osteoporotic women, whether bon
e status was defined by vertebral compression or by bone density. CONC
LUSIONS The increased obligatory calcium loss in osteoporotic women is
not due to an increase in the filtered load of calcium and must there
fore reflect reduced renal tubular reabsorption. This implies that the
calcium loss in the urine is not the result of increased bone resorpt
ion but is more likely to be causal.