Ec. Gokcen et al., PELVIC FRACTURE MECHANISM OF INJURY IN VEHICULAR TRAUMA PATIENTS, The journal of trauma, injury, infection, and critical care, 36(6), 1994, pp. 789-795
To investigate the correlation between motor vehicle crash mechanisms
and pelvic injury in front-seat occupants, we retrospectively reviewed
the clinical records of, and had complete crash reconstructions perfo
rmed for, 145 vehicular trauma patients with Injury Severity Scores gr
eater than 16 admitted to a level I trauma center. After excluding rea
r-seat and ejected occupants, 44 of the remaining 115 patients had pel
vic injuries. We excluded acetabular fractures and classified the rema
ining 26 pelvic ring fractures by the system of Young and Burgess: 20
lateral compression (LC) fractures, five anteroposterior compression (
APC) fractures, and one combined mechanical injury (CMI) fracture. Eig
hteen pelvic fractures were managed conservatively; eight required sur
gical intervention and four of those eight required emergent applicati
on of an external fixator for unresponsive hypotension. Trained invest
igation teams conducted the crash reconstructions, evaluating crash si
tes and vehicles with direct measurements of more than 500 variables.
Calculations from these data, e.g., direction of impact and change in
velocity at impact (DELTAV), were made with the CRASH III computer pro
gram and statistical analyses were performed using Chi-square and t te
sts. This information was then merged with the orthopedic evaluations.
We found that: (1) 72% of the pelvic fractures occurred in automobile
s with gross vehicular weights less than 2700 lb (compact and subcompa
ct) (p = 0.05); (2) the DELTAV was lower for lateral impacts than for
frontal impacts (24 mph vs. 32 mph, respectively; p = 0.0005); (3) mor
e victims of lateral than frontal impacts suffered pelvic fractures (5
0% vs. 7.5%, respectively, p = 0.0001); (4) more victims of lateral th
an frontal impacts suffered LC injuries (83% vs. 17%, respectively; p
< 0.0001); and (5) LC-II and LC-III fractures tended to occur at highe
r DELTAVs than did LC-1 fractures (29.0 mph vs. 23.5 mph, respectively
). We concluded that there was a direct correlation between pelvic inj
ury and vehicular mechanism of injury, substantiating the pelvic injur
y classification system of Young and Burgess, and that there is a need
for additional side impact protection in motor vehicles.