P. Joly et A. Morand, THEORETICAL HABITAT TEMPLETS, SPECIES TRAITS, AND SPECIES RICHNESS - AMPHIBIANS IN THE UPPER RHONE RIVER AND ITS FLOODPLAIN, Freshwater Biology, 31(3), 1994, pp. 455-468
1. The purpose of this study was to test predictions of the habitat te
mplet and the patch dynamics concept by analysing the relationship bet
ween either the species traits or species richness of amphibians and t
he spatial-temporal variability of eight habitat types of the Upper Rh
one River and its floodplain, France. 2. The information on species tr
aits of the twelve amphibian species was accumulated primarily from th
e literature; that on habitat utilization was based on field surveys.
The information was 'fuzzy coded', analysed by ordination techniques,
and finally linked to the spatial-temporal variability of habitat type
s elaborated elsewhere in this issue. 3. After elimination of the vari
ance caused by the differences between urodeles and anurans, correspon
dence analysis of the matrix of species traits demonstrated that the f
lexibility of the temporal pattern of reproduction was the major sourc
e of variation among amphibian species. A less significant source of v
ariation within anurans was related to traits usually linked to the co
ncept of r-K selection (potential number of descendants per reproducti
ve cycle and ratio of egg size to female size). 4. A correspondence an
alysis of habitat utilization by amphibian species separated four grou
ps of habitat types, corresponding to different degrees of influence t
hat the active channel had on adjacent waters in the floodplain (i.e.
from habitats that are most frequently disturbed by floods, to habitat
s of braided sections, old oxbow lakes, and the more terrestrialized h
abitats). 5. A co-inertia analysis of the relationship between species
traits and habitat utilization separated two habitat types (terrestri
alized former meanders and oxbow lakes) from the others. Species of te
rrestrialized habitats had a reproductive display, a low number of des
cendants per reproductive cycle, and a high ratio of egg size to femal
e size. Species of oxbow lakes were early or synchronous breeders, and
laid a single clutch. 6. Neither the predictions of the habitat templ
et concept nor those of the patch dynamics concept were validated. Spe
cies traits were not significantly correlated to the axes of the spati
al-temporal variability templet. The highest species richness was obse
rved in habitat types with the highest temporal variability; in additi
on, richness did not peak at highest spatial variability. 7. Deviation
from the predictions of the river habitat templet could be explained
by: (i) the over-simplification of this model with regard to the evolu
tion of the complex life cycles of the amphibians; and (ii) an underes
timation of the importance of phylogenetic constraints and the evoluti
on of community interactions.