T. Kandiah, EXPLODING THE THEORY OF UNIVERSALS IN ADULT 2ND-LANGUAGE TEACHING, IRAL. International review of applied linguistics in language teaching, 32(2), 1994, pp. 111-139
Citations number
60
Categorie Soggetti
Language & Linguistics","Education & Educational Research
Drawing on insights made available by the teaching of English in a con
text where there already exists an institutionalized New Variety of En
glish, and calculatedly adopting a somewhat conservative generative li
nguistic model, the paper discusses a bilingual teaching strategy that
, it argues, will permit the Universalist Hypothesis (UH) to be purpos
ively exploited in L2 classroom in a way that would dispel teachers' s
cepticism about the relevance of such linguistic abstractios to their
tasks. The strategy attempts to reconcile the best insights of the Con
trastive Hypothesis and the Identity Hypothesis, by looking at the mat
ching process (MP) learners naturally carry out across L1 and L2 in ne
ither the merely negative terms of the former nor the merely positive
terms of the latter, Where the languages share universal features, it
will assist the MP to go through. Where there are variations in the wa
y in which they draw on and realize the universals, resulting in learn
ing problems, it will help awaken learners to an intuitive awareness o
f universal possibilities which are used by L2 but which, owing to the
ir nonuse or different use by L1, lie dormant in their own L1 influenc
ed language faculty. Formalizing the MP as it is sophisticatedly carri
ed out in contact situations by competent bilinguals (who, after atl,
are what successful teaching courses would produce) by means of a cons
truct called Interlinguistic Transderivations (ITD), the paper will in
dicate how the strategy will carry out both these tasks along the line
s suggested by these ITD.