G. Harel et al., INVARIANCE OF RATIO - THE CASE OF CHILDRENS ANTICIPATORY SCHEME FOR CONSTANCY OF TASTE, Journal for research in mathematics education, 25(4), 1994, pp. 324-345
In this article we study the concept of invariance of ratio through an
investigation of children's understanding of constancy of taste-that
is, the notion that random samples of a given mixture taste the same-u
sing a device that does not resort to conventional symbolism. The pape
r begins with a definition of constancy of taste and other quantitativ
e analogues. Then it presents a theoretical analysis of how constancy
of taste may emerge from the child's additive world and grow into a co
nception where taste becomes an intensive quantity. The analysis sugge
sts that one's conception of taste constancy is linked in a fundamenta
l way to one's conception of invariance of ratio. Following this analy
sis, the paper reports a study that demonstrates the absence of taste
constancy among sixth-grade children. More specifically, the study sho
ws that sixth-grade children base their judgment of the relative stren
gth of the taste of two samples from the same mixture on at least one
of three (extraneous) variables: the relative volumes of the samples t
o be tasted, whether the mixture is thought of as consisting of a sing
le ingredient or more than one ingredient, and the relative amount of
the ingredients stated in the problem.