Pr. Tempest et al., A HUMANIZED ANTITUMOR NECROSIS FACTOR-ALPHA MONOCLONAL-ANTIBODY THAT ACTS AS A PARTIAL, COMPETITIVE ANTAGONIST OF THE TEMPLATE ANTIBODY, Hybridoma, 13(3), 1994, pp. 183-190
We have constructed several humanized versions of a monoclonal antibod
y (MAb78) against human tumor necrosis factor-alpha (huTNF-alpha) reta
ining the complementarity-determining regions (CDR) of the original mo
use MAb with or without a variable number of original framework region
(FR) residues. All versions, except one, showed a loss of binding aff
inity and neutralizing potency of at least 10-fold compared to the ori
ginal mouse MAb or its chimeric equivalent. In some cases, however, th
e decrease in neutralizing potency was significantly greater than the
decrease in binding affinity. Two humanized versions showing the great
est dissociation between these two parameters were studied for their c
apacity to inhibit the neutralizing activity of chimeric or murine MAb
78 when used at concentrations that bound but only partially neutraliz
ed huTNF-alpha. One humanized version (MAb78D) was indeed able to do s
o, whereas the other (MAb78C) was not found to exert any inhibitory ac
tivity at all concentrations tested. The antagonistic effect of MAb78D
was concentration dependent and could be overcome by increasing the c
oncentrations of chimeric or murine MAb78. Two different models of MAb
78-huTNF-alpha interaction that may help explain the antagonistic acti
vity of humanized MAb78D are discussed.