Theoretical calculations are presented for homogeneous and heterogeneo
us freezing of sulfuric acid droplets under stratospheric conditions,
based on classical nucleation theory. In contrast to previous results
it is shown that a prominent candidate for freezing, sulfuric acid tet
rahydrate (SAT = H2SO4.4H2O), does not freeze homogeneously. The theor
etical results limit the homogeneous freezing rate at 200 K to much le
ss than 1 cm-3s-1, a value that may be estimated from bulk phase labor
atory experiments. This suggests that the experimental value is likely
to be a measure of heterogeneous, not homogeneous nucleation. Thus, u
nder statospheric conditions, freezing of SAT can only occur in the pr
esence of suitable nuclei; however, even for heterogeneous nucleation
experimental results impose strong constraints. Since a nitric acid tr
ihydrate (NAT) embryo probably needs a solid body for nucleation, thes
e results put an important constraint on the theory of NAT formation i
n polar stratospheric clouds.