Ek. Birks et al., COMPARATIVE ASPECTS OF THE STRENGTH OF PULMONARY CAPILLARIES IN RABBIT, DOG, AND HORSE, Respiration physiology, 97(2), 1994, pp. 235-246
In previous studies of rabbit and dog lung, we demonstrated stress fai
lure of pulmonary capillaries at high transmural pressures (P-tm). The
P-tm necessary to elicit stress failure was 40 cmH(2)O higher in dog
than rabbit, and the total blood-gas barrier (BGB) thickness was great
er in dog than rabbit. This suggests that stress failure may be relate
d to BGB thickness, and is consistent with the Laplace relationship wh
ich states that wall stress is proportional to capillary radius but in
versely proportional to wall thickness. In the present studies, we com
pared BGB thickness and an index of capillary radius in lungs from 3 r
abbits, 3 dogs, and 2 horses perfusion fixed at a P-tm of similar to 3
0 cmH(2)O. Thicknesses of the BGB were measured at right angles to the
barrier at random points on the capillary wall determined by test lin
e intersections. Capillary radius was determined from the mean of majo
r and minor axes measured on electron micrographs. Capillary pressure
for failure in the horse was taken to be the mean of pulmonary arteria
l and left atrial pressures observed in galloping thoroughbreds known
to develop exercise-induced pulmonary hemorrhage, although the actual
pressure required for failure may be less than this. Average capillary
radii were 3.6, 3.4, and 3.2 mu m for rabbits, dogs, and horses, resp
ectively. We found that the BGB was thinnest in the rabbit, intermedia
te in the dog, and thickest in the horse. Calculated capillary wall st
ress values for the median total BGB thickness at a nominal P-tm of 30
cmH(2)O were 2.5 x 10(4), 1.7 x 10(4), and 1.5 x 10(4) N.m(-2) for ra
bbits, dogs, and horses, respectively. This species ranking fits with
the pressures required to cause stress failure which are approximately
50, 90, and 130 cmH(2)O in rabbit, dog, and horse, respectively. We c
onclude that the differences in capillary radius of curvature and BGB
thickness account for some of the observed differences in P-tm necessa
ry to cause stress failure. However, other factors may also be importa
nt in determining the strength of the BGB.