The Neogene cheilostomatous bryozoan Celleporaria palmata lived facult
atively in association with the scleractinian coral Culicia. For Culic
ia the association was obligatory, the symbiosis was most probably mut
ualistic. Benefits for the coral appear to have been: (1) the bryozoan
provided substrate in a soft-bottom environment; (2) the coral could
feed at higher levels above the sediment; (3) the feeding currents gen
erated by the bryozoan provided the corals with food (no competition f
or food would occur as the coral would collect larger prey); and (4) t
he surrounding of the corallites by the bryozoan provided strength and
lateral protection. Benefits for the bryozoan appear to have been: (1
) the stinging cells of the coral provided protection against predator
s and settlers; (2) the positioning of the corals on the maculae saved
the bryozoan subsequent energy expenditure in further construction of
polymorphs and secondary calcification. Negative effects for the bryo
zoan might have been the inhibition of possible functions of the macul
ae other than as exhalant chimneys, e.g., production and generation of
male gametes.