D. Garcia et al., SEDIMENTARY FRACTIONATIONS BETWEEN AL, TI, AND ZR AND THE GENESIS OF STRONGLY PERALUMINOUS GRANITES, The Journal of geology, 102(4), 1994, pp. 411-422
Sedimentary sorting produces alternating shales and sandstones with co
mplementary chemistries. The preferential partitioning of quartz and z
ircon in the coarse-grained fraction of the sediments results in a str
ong fractionation between SiO2, Zr, and other components (Al2O3, TiO2
...). As a consequence, shales may be defined chemically as having hig
her Al2O3/SiO2 and TiO2/Zr ratios than their source rocks; sandstones
have the opposite characteristics and vary in composition according to
the maturity of their source and the intensity of sorting processes.
Most sedimentary suites display a good correlation between Al2O3/SiO2
and TiO2/Zr. This result is used to evaluate an average bulk compositi
on for recent clastic materials and to model their composition on a te
rnary Al-Ti-Zr diagram. Because the Al2O3/TiO2 ratio of igneous rocks
is highly sensitive to magmatic differentiation, igneous and sedimenta
ry trends crosscut in the Al-Ti-Zr diagram. In the case of strongly pe
raluminous granites (SPG), genetic models based on crustal melting and
restite separation are in conflict with the observed Al-Ti-Zr relatio
ns because: (1) most SPG suites are displaced toward low TiO2/Zr ratio
s when compared to their potential metasedimentary sources, and (2) ma
ny SPG are too rich in Zr and Ti to be produced from calc-alkaline fel
sic sources in the restite model. These features suggest that the bulk
Zr and Ti budget of SPG is dominated by (relatively hot) melt contrib
utions, not by recycled solid materials.