Two canonical pattern forming systems, the Rayleigh-Benard convection
and the Turing mechanism for biological pattern formation, are compare
d. The similarity and fundamental differences in the mathematical stru
cture of the two systems are addressed, with special emphasis on how t
he linear onset of patterns is affected by the finite size and the bou
ndary conditions. Our analysis is facilitated by continuously varying
the boundary condition, from one that admits simple algebraic solution
of the problem but is unrealistic to another which is physically real
izable. Our investigation shows that the size dependence of the convec
tion problem can be considered generic, in the sense that for the majo
rity of boundary conditions the same trend is to be observed, while fo
r the corresponding Turing mechanism one will rely crucially on the as
sumed boundary conditions to ensure that a particular sequence of patt
erns be picked up as the system grows in size. This suggests that, alt
hough different systems might exhibit similar pattern forming features
, it is still possible to distinguish them by characteristics which ar
e specific to the individual models.