Sm. Anlage et al., ELECTRODYNAMICS OF ND1.85CE0.15CUO4 - COMPARISON WITH NB AND YBA2CU3O7-DELTA, Physical review. B, Condensed matter, 50(1), 1994, pp. 523-535
We have measured the surface impedance of Nd1.85Ce0.15CuO4 (NCCO) thin
films and single crystals, YBa2Cu3O7-delta (YBCO) single crystals, an
d Nb single crystals. We find that the electrodynamic properties of Nb
are in good agreement with s-wave BCS theory. YBCO single crystals sh
ow behavior which has been seen only in very high quality materials an
d which is clearly not consistent with s-wave BCS theory. Both thin fi
lms and single crystals of NCCO have been grown, thoroughly characteri
zed, and measured at microwave frequencies. We find an unusual degree
of consistency in the results between thin films and crystals of NCCO.
We also find a surprisingly good agreement between the temperature de
pendence of the surface impedance, and single-gap BCS s-wave calculati
ons over the entire temperature range. These results are puzzling in t
he light of the fact that NCCO is a cuprate superconductor, and the cr
ystals were grown in a manner very similar to those of YBCO. We discus
s these results and consider a variety of ideas currently in the liter
ature which may explain these striking differences.