Fourteen laboratories participated in a collaborative study to compare
abilities of AOAC modified copper catalyst Kjeldahl method, 978.02, a
nd the generic combustion method, 990.03, to analyze the nitrogen cont
ent of fertilizer materials. Combustion analyses are more time efficie
nt, more accurate, and less hazardous than Kjeldahl analyses. There we
re 3 different types of instrumentation involved in the collaborative
study: (1) Leco FP-428 Nitrogen Determinator; (2) Perkin-Elmer 2410 Se
ries II Nitrogen Analyzer; (3) Carlo-Erba 1500 Series II Nitrogen Anal
yzer. Thirty samples of fertilizer containing 167% N included 2 ACS gr
ade standard materials: ammonium nitrate, theory 35.00% N; and dicyand
iamide, theory 66.64% N. A diammonium phosphate and urea mixture (3 1; 1.0 mm grind) and 2 ACS grade standard materials of ammonium nitrat
e and ammonium sulfate were supplied for repetitive combustion analyse
s. Overall method performance of the combustion method was at least as
good as the modified Kjeldahl method. Repeatability standard deviatio
n (S(r)) values for the combustion method ranged from 0.09 to 0.34 vs
the modified Kjeldahl method range of 0.06-0.49; reproducibility stand
ard deviation (S(R)) values for the combustion method ranged from 0.13
to 1.07 vs the range of 0.09-3.57 for the modified Kjeldahl method. T
he grand mean was 20.78% for the combustion method, and 20.79% for the
modified Kjeldahl method using various fertilizers. The average range
s Of S(r) and S(R) for the methods were, respectively, 0.17 and 0.29 f
or the combustion method, and 0.19 and 0.54 for the modified Kjeldahl
method. The method was adopted first action by AOAC INTERNATIONAL.