In this article we present generalized theoretical models of mate attr
action in acoustic communication. The models use simple decision rules
for females and show theoretical differences between the rules in rel
ative attraction of females to sound sources (calling males). The impo
rtant variables of the models are the relative powers of the sources,
the distance between the sources and the number of competing signalers
. Relative attraction among sources is a function of their relative po
wer output with more powerful signals attracting more females. Using d
ifferent assumptions about the spacing of sources with respect to fema
le sensitivity, data from phonotaxis studies can be explained well by
either random pick or active choice models. Bioacousticians must reexa
mine the use of, and conclusions based on, the two choice playback par
adigm in studying female mate choice.