X. Quidelleur et al., LONG-TERM GEOMETRY OF THE GEOMAGNETIC-FIELD FOR THE LAST 5 MILLION YEARS - AN UPDATED SECULAR VARIATION DATABASE, Geophysical research letters, 21(15), 1994, pp. 1639-1642
Lee [1983] assembled more than two thousand paleomagnetic directional
data from lava flows in 65 sampling sites with ages spanning the last
5 million years. Constable [1992] recently suggested that the virtual
geomagnetic poles (VGP) derived from this data base have been preferen
tially located within two antipodal bands of longitude. We have reanal
yzed and updated the Lee data base, yielding a total of 3179 data from
86 distinct sites. Neither the total data set, nor various subsets of
the data unambiguously show any large and clear maxima in the longitu
de distribution of VGPs. The shape of the common site longitude distri
bution is far more striking with a pronounced (and robust) minimum clo
se to the common site longitude and secondary maxima about 120-degrees
away from it. The former (first order) feature is equivalent to the f
ar-sided effect discovered by Wilson [1970] and corresponds to a persi
stent axial quadrupole amounting to about 5% of the axial dipole, as p
reviously found by several authors. The latter (second order) feature
could correspond to the VGP biasing effect described by Egbert [1992]
although its observed amplitude appears larger than predicted. Part of
this effect (an asymmetry in the maxima) may also correspond to Wilso
n's [1971] right-handed effect. Given only a small axial quadrupolar c
omponent and the very uneven actual site distribution, the expected lo
ngitude distribution of VGPs can be calculated: this is found to be in
good agreement with the paleomagnetic observations (i.e. rather flat
with a moderate maximum near 120-degrees-E). This study emphasizes pro
blems related to the unsatisfactory distribution of sites. The amplitu
de and significance of other terms, beyond the dominant axial dipole a
nd significant axial quadrupole contribution, remain to be assessed.