D. Kahn et al., CAPTOPRIL-ENHANCED (99)TC(M)-MAG3 RENAL SCINTIGRAPHY IN SUBJECTS WITHSUSPECTED RENOVASCULAR HYPERTENSION, Nuclear medicine communications, 15(7), 1994, pp. 515-528
This pilot study was undertaken to generate preliminary data on the ac
curacy of captopril-enhanced renal scintigraphy with a relatively new
radiopharmaceutical, Tc-99m-mercaptoacetyltriglycine (Tc-99m-MAG3) for
detecting significant renal artery stenosis. Truth data was based eit
her on arteriographic or outcome criteria (blood pressure response to
therapy). Twenty-seven subjects with suspected renovascular hypertensi
on were studied with baseline and captopril-enhanced Tc-99m-MAG3 renal
scintigraphy and renal arteriography. Scan interpretations were expre
ssed as a probability of a significant renal artery stenosis. Scan int
erpretations were compared with renal arteriographic results, renal ve
in renin levels, blood pressure values after renal artery repair, and
blood pressure control after 4-26 months of clinical follow-up. Using
greater-than-or-equal-to 50% luminal obstruction on arteriography as t
he reference standard for renal artery stenosis and a high probability
scan representing a positive test, the test sensitivity and specifici
ty were 33 and 97%, respectively (using high or indeterminate probabil
ity to represent a positive scan, the test sensitivity and specificity
were 67 and 83%, respectively). The negative predictive value of a lo
w probability scan for renal artery stenosis was 80%. However, includi
ng a measure of renovascular hypertension (blood pressure response to
renal artery repair) as the reference standard, the accuracy of the sc
an improves, with the negative predictive value of a low probability s
can for renovascular hypertension increasing to 97%. Scintigraphic res
ults were also positively correlated with renal vein renin values in a
statistically significant fashion (two-tailed Fisher exact test stati
stic = 6.43, P = 0.0219). Captopril-enhanced Tc-99m-MAG3 renal scintig
raphy is a moderately accurate technique for detecting renal artery st
enosis. More importantly, our preliminary findings suggest that the sc
intigraphic technique using Tc-99m-MAG3 appears to predict the blood p
ressure response to renal artery repair in subjects with suspected ren
ovascular hypertension, thereby separating subjects with haemodynamica
lly insignificant renal artery stenosis from those with renovascular h
ypertension.