C. Vickers et al., PREVENTION OF REBLEEDING FROM ESOPHAGEAL-VARICES - 2-YEAR FOLLOW-UP OF A PROSPECTIVE CONTROLLED TRIAL OF PROPRANOLOL IN ADDITION TO SCLEROTHERAPY, Journal of hepatology, 21(1), 1994, pp. 81-87
A prospective randomised trial comparing propranolol and sclerotherapy
to sclerotherapy alone was conducted over a 2-year follow up in a dis
trict hospital setting of unselected patients. Rebleeding and survival
were analysed. Thirty-nine patients were randomised to propranolol pl
us sclerotherapy and 34 to sclerotherapy alone. The two groups were cl
inically comparable. There was no significant difference in the cumula
tive percent of patients free of rebleeding; 54% of the sclerotherapy
group rebled compared to 52% of the group treated with propranolol plu
s sclerotherapy (Hazard ratio 1.09 (0.54-2.22) and p=0.81, NS). Two-ye
ar actuarial survival was also not significantly different, with 77% o
f the propanolol plus sclerotherapy group surviving, compared to 74% o
f sclerotherapy alone (Hazard ratio 1.08 (0.35-2.22) and p=0.79, NS).
The mean time to eradication of varices was not significantly differen
t between the two groups (propranolol plus sclerotherapy 222 days, scl
erotherapy alone 243 days), nor did the rate of variceal recurrence di
ffer (72.7 vs 72 days). This study did not show long-term improvement
in rebleeding or survival using propranolol in addition to a regular s
clerotherapy programme. (C) Journal of Hepatology.