Mi. Zimmerman et al., ESTIMATED VS ACTUAL VALUES FOR DEAD SPACE TIDAL VOLUME RATIOS DURING INCREMENTAL EXERCISE IN PATIENTS EVALUATED FOR DYSPNEA/, Chest, 106(1), 1994, pp. 131-136
The physiologic dead space/tidal volume ratio (VD/VT) at rest and duri
ng exercise is a sensitive measurement of gas exchange that reflects m
atching of ventilation to perfusion, but requires an invasive measurem
ent for its calculation. Determining VD/VT noninvasively uses estimati
ons of arterial PCO2 based on the end-tidal PCO2. To further standardi
ze incremental cardiopulmonary exercise testing, we compared actual VD
/VT With estimated VD/VT values in 35 patients referred for evaluation
of dyspnea. Estimates of VD/VT used the Jones' equation (VD/VT[J]) de
rived from healthy subjects during steady-tate exercise or PETCO(2) al
one (VD/VT[ET]) to approximate PaCO2. At rest, mean values for VD/VT(J
) and actual VD/VT Were not different: 0.372 +/- 0.08 vs 0.376 +/-0.09
, p = not significant (NS). Each method identified Si percent of value
s greater than or equal to 0.36. In 26 subjects who achieved higher wo
rk rates, the mean difference between actual VD/VT and VD/VT(J) increa
sed from 0.009 +/- 0.04 (NS) at impairment. low work rate (Vo(2) = 28.
3 percent pred max) to 0.040 +/- 0.06 at high work rate (VO2 = 54.7 pe
rcent pred max), p = 0.006. Actual VD/VT identified 18 (69 percent) pa
tients as abnormal vs 13 (50 percent) so identified by VD/VT(J). With
exercise, VD/VT(J) was no better than VD/VT(ET). We conclude that duri
ng incremental exercise in a patient population, methods for estimatin
g VD/VT progressively underestimate this measurement; and therefore, '
'normal'' estimated VD/VT values may fail to identify underlying pulmo
nary and/or pulmonary vascular impairment.