Pr. Garrett et al., AN EXPERIMENTAL-STUDY OF THE ANTIFOAM BEHAVIOR OF MIXTURES OF A HYDROCARBON OIL AND HYDROPHOBIC PARTICLES, Colloids and surfaces. A, Physicochemical and engineering aspects, 85(2-3), 1994, pp. 159-197
An experimental study of the synergistic antifoam behaviour of hydroph
obic particle-hydrocarbon oil mixtures is presented here. The system f
or study has been selected to minimise specific effects in order to hi
ghlight the phenomenology of the antifoam process. Thus, liquid paraff
in and a commercial sodium alkyl benzenesulphonate were chosen as oil
and surfactant respectively, because this oil exhibited a negative spr
eading coefficient at the air-water surface of the solution of that su
rfactant under all circumstances investigated. These circumstances inc
luded situations where the air-water surface was rapidly expanded to r
epresent the conditions prevailing during foam generation. In the main
, finely divided silica, hydrophobised with trimethylsilane, was used
as the particulate component. Again, this material had no tendency to
spread at air-water surfaces and had no effect on the spreading behavi
our of the liquid paraffin. The study was also extended to include exa
mples of intrinsically hydrophobic organic particles such as calcium s
tearyl acid phosphate. Contact angles, electrophoretic mobilities, ele
ctron microscopy and observations of emulsion behaviour all suggested
that these oil-particle mixtures form composite entities where the par
ticles tend to adhere to the oil-water surface with a contact angle (m
easured through the aqueous phase) theta(ow) > pi/2. The particles als
o exhibited a finite contact angle theta(aw) at the air-water surface
so that theta(aq) < pi/2. Weak antifoam effects associated with the pa
rticles alone probably concerned dewetting and bridging in foam films
to form holes in a manner analogous to that found previously with poly
tetrafluoroethylene particles. Preliminary observations indicated that
the presence of particles adhering to the oil-water surface facilitat
es the emergence of oil droplets into the air-water surface by rupturi
ng unsymmetrical oil-water-air films. The observations reported here a
re consistent with an antifoam mechanism where oil droplets form mecha
nically unstable bridging lenses in foam films. Formation of such conf
igurations requires rupture of oil-water-air films by particles. The c
ontact angle requirement for rupture of such films is less severe than
that required for symmetrical air-water-air films. Therefore particle
s may promote the emergence of oil droplets into air-water surfaces to
form lenses without themselves exhibiting significant antifoam effect
s.