One hundred seventy-six consecutive patients with chronic low-back pai
n and no history of previous lumbar surgery were studied to test the c
linical criteria of Fairbank et al. and Helbig and Lee for zygapophysi
al joint pain. All patients underwent a history, examination, and a se
ries of zygapophysial joint injections or blocks of the medial branche
s of the dorsal ramus with lignocaine. Those patients responding to th
e first series of blocks were given confirmatory blocks using bupivaca
ine. None of the clinical features tested was found to be associated w
ith response to the confirmatory block. The Fairbank et al. and Helbig
and Lee criteria were shown to be unreliable in distinguishing pain o
f zygapophysial joint origin from pain of other origins.