M. Noland et al., CORRELATED CAPPED SUBSYSTEM METHOD FOR THE CALCULATION OF SUBSTITUENTEFFECTS ON BOND-ENERGIES, The journal of physical chemistry. A, Molecules, spectroscopy, kinetics, environment, & general theory, 101(7), 1997, pp. 1193-1197
The correlated capped small system strategy has been demonstrated to b
e a valuable method for the calculation of bond energies and substitue
nt effects on bond energies. By using the integrated molecular orbital
-molecular orbital formulation, this strategy provides a means for int
roducing electron correlation effects in cases where a correlated calc
ulation on the entire system is not affordable, but both electron corr
elation on a part of the system and substituent effects from another p
art are required for obtaining accurate results. To apply this dual-le
vel strategy to very large systems, one may consider various lower lev
els for which the calculation on the whole system is affordable. In th
e present work, we examine the behavior of several such lower levels,
in particular semiempirical molecular orbital methods based on neglect
of diatomic differential overlap, ab initio Hartree-Fock calculations
with small basis sets, and density functional theory. The methods are
tested for calculating C-H bond energies and substituent effects in a
series of substituted ethanes with the general formula CH(3)CH(2)X. T
he entire systems considered here are ethane (X = H), propane (X = CH3
), ethanol (X OH), ethylamine (X = NH2), and fluoroethane (X = F). For
11 of the 13 dual-level methods that we tested, bond energies are mor
e accurate in the dual-level calculation than in either single-level c
alculation (high level on capped small system or low level on entire s
ystem); thus, integrating the levels is found to be a successful strat
egy. Substituent effects are also more accurate with the dual-level st
rategy.