Wa. Helbing et al., LONG-TERM RESULTS OF ATRIAL CORRECTION FOR TRANSPOSITION OF THE GREAT-ARTERIES - COMPARISON OF MUSTARD AND SENNING OPERATIONS, Journal of thoracic and cardiovascular surgery, 108(2), 1994, pp. 363-372
Few data exists on the differences in long-term outcome between Mustar
d and Senning operations. We reviewed available data of all hospital s
urvivors of these operations and assessed risk factors for late death
and sinus node dysfunction. Of those patients undergoing the Mustard o
peration, 60 were hospital survivors (46 simple transposition, 14 comp
lex); of those patients undergoing the Senning operation, 62 were hosp
ital survivors (43 simple, 19 complex). Median duration of follow-up w
as 16 yeats (maximum 25 years) for Mustard operation, 11 years (maximu
m 20 years) for Senning operation. No reoperations were done, except f
or pacemaker implantation. No differences were found between the two g
roups with regard to baffle-associated problems, right ventricular fai
lure, sudden death (6% in both groups), and functional status at final
follow-up (New York Heart Association class I or II except for four p
atients). For patients undergoing the Mustard operation, survival at 1
6-year follow-up was 91% with simple transposition and 60% with comple
x transposition (p = 0.027); for both groups of: patients undergoing t
he Senning operation, survival at 16-year follow-up was 78%. Survival
in the absence of rhythm disturbance at 16-year follow-up was 18% for
Mustard operation and 53% for Senning operation (p < 0.001). In multiv
ariate analysis, significant,independent risk factors for late death t
urned out to be complex transposition (versus simple) and active arrhy
thmias. The only significant risk factor for the occurrence of sinus n
ode dysfunction was the Mustard operation. We conclude that apart from
the difference in the loss of sinus rhythm, no differences were found
in the long-term clinical results of the two types of operations.