Ca. Morris et al., SOME GENETIC-FACTORS AFFECTING TEMPERAMENT IN BOS-TAURUS CATTLE, New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research, 37(2), 1994, pp. 167-175
Temperament scores were recorded by two operators on a herd of Bos tau
rus beef cattle, including Angus and Hereford controls and various cro
ssbred groups. The herd consisted of 765 cows, 653 calves at foot (ave
rage age 2 months), and 250 yearling heifers. Recording of temperament
in the yards was carried out at weighing time in November 1982 using
a 1-8 scale, and immediately afterwards when the herd was drafted for
natural mating using a 1-6 scale, with higher scores indicating more d
ifficulty experienced by stockmen in carrying out the routine weighing
and drafting operations. In addition, a calving temperament score was
recorded on 2121 cows calving in 1981-90 using a 0-5 scale. Both scor
es in the yards differed significantly among cow breed groups (P < 0.0
01). The range of means was 1.73 units (1.86 phenotypic standard devia
tions: sigma) or the weighing score (Score 1) and 1.57 units (1.29sigm
a) for the drafting score (Score 2). Corresponding data for yearling b
reed groups were 1.11sigma for Score 1 (P < 0.001) and 0.49sigma for S
core 2 (not significant), and for calf breed groups 0.99sigma for Scor
e 1 (P < 0.001) and 0.90sigma for Score 2 (P < 0.01). The heritability
for average cow score in the yards (untransformed scale) was 0.22 +/-
0.15 (based on 176 sires), for average yearling score was 0.32 +/- 0.
24 (47 sire groups), and for average calf score was 0.23 +/- 0.12 (53
different sire groups). Transforming data to a logarithmic scale made
little difference to these estimates. Cow's calving temperament score
had a heritability of 0.09 +/- 0.03 (486 sires) and a repeatability of
0.20 +/- 0.02. The correlation of average weighing/drafting scores fo
r cow-calf pairs was 0.27, or 0.14 after adjustment for breed group. C
orrelations among breed groups were 0.49 for Scores 1 and 2 from cows,
0.65 for mean scores from cows and yearlings, 0.79 for mean scores fr
om yearlings and calves, and 0.54 for mean scores from cows and calves
. It was concluded that there were generally significant differences a
mong breeds for temperament scores, and that breeds ranked similarly o
ver the various age groups. Cow differences within breed were repeatab
le, but heritable effects were generally small.